Insurance in the Real World
Originally Published: November 2026/Last Reviewed: November 2026
When an insurance premium increases by 20%, it’s natural to assume the insurance company raised its rates by 20%.
But that’s not necessarily what happened.
An insurance rate and an insurance premium are related, but they aren’t the same thing.
What’s the Difference?
A rate is the price charged for a specified unit of insurance exposure.
A premium is the amount charged for a policy, calculated using applicable rates, exposure information, and other rating factors.
Consider a simplified example involving general liability insurance rated on annual sales.
Suppose the insurer charges $5 per $1,000 of sales.
| Previous Year | Current Year | |
| Annual sales | $500,000 | $600,000 |
| Rate per $1,000 | $5.00 | $5.00 |
| Calculated premium | $2,500 | $3,000 |
The premium increased 20%, but the rate didn’t change.
The increase resulted entirely from greater sales.
Actual pricing often involves minimum premiums, classifications, credits, debits, and other factors, but the distinction remains important.
How Are Insurance Rates Developed?
Insurers employ actuaries and other specialists to analyze the cost of providing coverage.
Among the factors considered are:
- Claims frequency and severity.
- Trends in repair costs, medical expenses, litigation, and other claim-related costs.
- Administrative expenses, commissions, and reinsurance costs.
- Investment income, capital requirements, and financial objectives.
Historical losses provide a starting point, but insurers must also estimate future claim costs.
That’s particularly challenging when losses are affected by severe weather, construction costs, medical inflation, or legal developments.
Why Do Insurers Charge Different Premiums?
Insurers may have different claims experience, underwriting standards, operating expenses, reinsurance arrangements, and expectations about future losses.
One insurer may welcome a particular type of business while another considers it undesirable.
Differences in coverage and deductibles also affect pricing.
Consequently, two insurers may quote substantially different premiums for seemingly similar insurance.
What About State Regulation?
Insurance rates are subject to state laws and regulatory requirements, although oversight varies by state, coverage, and insurer.
Some rates require prior approval. Others may be used subject to filing requirements or subsequent review. Certain insurance markets operate under different arrangements.
Rate regulation doesn’t mean every insurer must charge the same price.
Something to Consider
A renewal premium can change because of payroll, revenue, property values, operations, claims experience, coverage changes, or the insurer’s rates.
Understanding why a premium changed is often more useful than knowing how much it changed.
Important Information
This article provides general information about insurance and risk management. Insurance policies, laws, and individual circumstances vary. Coverage and obligations are determined by the applicable policy provisions and other governing documents.
